Guest Post: On Favorites

Without further adieu, this week has a very special guest poster – my beautiful wife, Crystal. A woman of many talents: she tries to juggle, she has amazing flow, mother of cats, breaker of bread, Queen of the Andals, etc etc.

When Shawshank initially asked me to write something for him, I declined. For one thing, my own blog isn’t on any particular topic. I can’t very well come over into his space and post about my life. He asked me to post about favorite books. I don’t work well when I’m given asked to do something as a favor, and even worse when I’m given a topic.

But, I’m willing to do it.

I don’t think I could come up with an absolute favorite book if I tried. I’ve never finished a book and thought, that book fucking changed my life. On the other hand, it doesn’t take long for regular readers to see Shawshank’s undying love for House of Leaves or Twilight. Maybe it’s the circumstances surrounding them that makes them special to him. It’s that idea that ties into my thought about what makes books special to us.

For a long time, my favorite book was a copy of 1001 Questions Answered About the Seashore. It wasn’t my book, it was one of the maybe 10 or so books at my grandparents’ summer beach home. I read it nightly whenever I was down there, it was almost a ritual. Read the book at night, and preach its knowledge at the beach during the day. It was a favorite, but why?

Hold that thought.

When I was 12, my homeroom was next to the school’s library. That’s where I first discovered Gone With the Wind. I still consider it one of my favorite books. It catches a lot of shit for the subject matter and language. Will it change your life? Not in the least. But my grandmother and I bonded over my library’s copy. “It’s amazing, right there in the library for you”, she said. “When it came out, I had to sneak it out with me to babysitting jobs if I wanted to read it”.

One of my most common replies to the “what’s your favorite book?” question is usually Stephen King’s IT. Is it King’s best work? Even I, who holds it above others in my list of favorite King books, don’t consider it his best. So… why is it a favorite? Because my copy was my grandfather’s. He had signed the inside cover, like he did with all of his books. I was about 9 when IT was released, and the cover was spooky. Five summers later, IT replaced 1001 Questions as my favorite summertime read. I asked my grandfather if I could read it. He looked at my mother for guidance. “Just give it to her”, she said. “She understands the dirty stuff, and she’ll sneak it out and read it anyway.”

They’re all favorite books of mine, even though the contents of each is as varied and different as my hair colors in any given month. I look at those times now and remember how it felt to be able to identify flounder and comb jellies and the ultra-rare sightings of pipe fish. I can feel the hot rocks under my feet while I climbed barefoot in search of tidal pools. It’s nothing to be transported back to my happy 12-year old self, talking to my grandmother about scandals and racism. If I close my eyes, I can smell the hot cut grass in the common area of the apartment complex, taste the frozen lemonade while I read IT under the crab apple trees.

They’re not favorite books because they’re amazing, well-written pieces of literature. However, they’re all special, at least to me.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

12 thoughts on “Guest Post: On Favorites

  1. Hmmm… Interesting. I’d also tend to say that I don’t have ONE favourite book. When it comes to King’s IT, it was my first step into the world of Stephen King. I remember that one of our weekly magazines here printed it, one chapter weekly, and I was fascinated. From then on I read everything from King that I could get. But the book from him that I remember most was The Stand. I spent hours and days reading it, from the moment I got home from school til the moment I had to go to bed, and Fleetwood Mac’s ‘Big Love’ was on a continuous loop on my headphones, so the book and the song will stay linked in my head forever. And ‘Big Love’ is still on my eternal playlist, so from time to time it remembers me of that book.
    Must I mention that the film and tv versions where underwhelming? To say the least. The only good King films are Shawshank Redemption (ha!) and The Green Mile. And yes, I did not mention The Shining on purpose. The book is worlds better.
    1. The TV miniseries of IT was such a terrible waste of the talent they had. I don’t understand where it gets all the love. The first half the recent movie was so good, in my opinion. I think that’s why the second half is such a shitty disappointment.

      I firmly maintain my stance that only King’s short(er) stories make good movies. “Shawshank Redemption”, “Stand By Me”, both great. “1922”, pretty good. “The Langoliers” is good for entertainment. “The Mist” is probably one of my favorite movies in general. His full length stuff can be amazing reads, but it can be BLOATED, and I think the movies and series suffer for it sometimes.

      1. “The Dome”. I rest my case.

        The book alone was meh, but the series was an abomination. First it has very little to do with the book (I mean, The Simpsons Movie was closer to that book!), and it gets even worse because King had a cameo in it and was a producer, so he actually EMBRACED this pile of shit!

        1. I think the reason I never got into the TV series because I was so bitter about how very mediocre “Under the Dome” was as a book. That book turned Shawshank off from trying more King for years.

          1. For me, King’s traffic accident some years ago marked a turning point. From then on his books were different and -IMHO- not as good anymore. I started reading some of them, but finished none. When that car hit him, something snapped. He lost his ability to write books which would immerse you as a reader, take a grip on you.
        1. Had to read about it on Wikipedia. Foolish me. Now I can’t watch that movie. It’s a bit like 6th sense, the punchline’s ruined. 😉